You are here

Trying to update version 3.0 model from 2002 to current version 3.6 -- slight differences

Hello, I am updating a version 3.0 model from 2002 to version 3.6. It is of a mining pit lake with a surface inflow and surface outflow. To keep it simple the only constituent used is TDS. I am using the exact same boundary conditions (bathymetry file, meteorology file, inflow, outflow, initial conditions, T and TDS of inflow, etc.). I have gone through the control file over and over and believe I have converted everything to the version 3.6 input format, keeping the same inputs from the original model. When I run the model, my results track the 2002 results fairly well in terms of trends, but they are not identical. Should they be identical? There seems to be some differences in vertical mixing. Have any changes been made in the algorithms related to vertical mixing since 2002? I have plotted up vertical profiles of T and TDS vs. depth, monthly for one year of simulation. I could send this along if it would help to see the differences. Basically I need to model current and possible future conditions, but am reluctant to proceed until I am confident that the version 3.6 model is as correct as I can get it, matching the original model results. Do you have any ideas? Thanks, Brian Park
Forums: 

Hello Brian, I asked Scott Wells about your question and this is what he said: "A couple items to keep in mind: Use NPROC=1 for strict reproducibility. Now in V3.6 the wind shear on the surface is dictated by the value Z0 in the control file - in V3.0 it was fixed in the code - in fact in V3.0 it used 2 different values- one for evaporation and one for the surface wind stress which was not consistent. There were also a few bug fixes on vertical diffusivity near a boundary that were fixed since V3.0. Also the new TKE algorithms had many bug fixes applied that may influence local rate of turbulent mixing - but I do not think they were in V3.0. Scott " Hope this helps, Chris