You are here

Calibration with water balance tool

Hi, sorry this is not really a technical question, but I'm new to modelling, and I'm just wondered if anybody can give advice on how they've transitioned from the water balance stage to the temperature calibration stage using the water balance tool and distributed tributary (DT) file? That is to say, when calibrating the water balance when you first start modelling should the wind shelter coefficient (WSC) be left at 1.0 (I'm modelling a reservoir and evaporation is quite important so is switched on) for the water balance, and the difference in flows to close the balance be adjusted in the DT file? Or if the WSC gives you a better result at say 0.8 should the water balance be closed with this (with less adjusted flows required in the DT file). I feel like adjusting the WSC is going into the sensitivity analysis of the temperature calibration, but my supervisor said the water balance is closed first and then you move on to temperature so it's almost two separate stages. If calibration is ongoing, then have people re-calibrated and re-adjusted their DT files ongoing with the water balance tool as well when they adjust say WSC or inflow temperatures, or have their DT files stayed exactly the same from their very first run? Not many modellers outside of W2 use something like the water balance tool, so it's difficult to seek advice. Appreciate any comments, I'm so confused........thank you!!!
Forums: 

Hi Julie. You can not say one job is done and now I go to the next job. Always you need to go back and adjust the previous steps. But the rate of adjustments are smaller. You need to adjust the water balance in your temperature calibration again. But I believe it should be small. Proceed to your next step and do the temperature calibration. Again when you finish the temperature calibration for WQ calibrations you need to adjust the parameters again. For example, in temperature calibration, you are using the light extinction coefficient. When you start WQ calibration this parameter changes as a function of algae and TSS concentrations and consequently change the light penetration to the water column. Or the density changes as a function of TSS. So again you need to go back and do the temperature calibration as well. In each step of your calibration, when you reached to an acceptable results go to the next step. You will do the fine tuning in your final step (WQ calibration). For SHADE ans WSC, I believe you have to start with 1, unless the lake is narrow and there are extensive vegetation and topography barriers around the lake.

Thanks Amir, the forum never told me I had a reply, sorry for the delayed thank you!

You are welcome Julie.